A while back I wanted to try Magball arms on my NoStock Max v2. Picked up a set, and printed myself some adapters to use them. Ended up designing and printing my own effector plate. I was previously using an effector plate & hotend mount made by 713maker.com, and I based my new magball effector plate on his mount.
I was very happy with the result, but of course there were minor inaccuracies, so I decided to change the model, and flatten it out to be milled. I talked to Matt @ 713maker.com and he took it on as a custom job. I got them today and popped them on, couldn't be happier.
Haven't printed yet (was in the middle of changing some wiring around when the effector arrived) but it went on just fine. Looks great, and is super smooth.
Yes, it's on the big side, costing me a little Delta radius, but allows lots of room for the hotend and layer fans, etc. All the arms have a 50mm spacing.
Edit: If you'll be at MRRF, I'll have this there and be printing with it. Stop and say hi!
Last edited by kraegar (17 March 2017 18:50)
No visible tilt. Can't find my spirit level, but planning to measure the tilt.
Here's a heightmap:
(still have the odd taco bowl shape thing going on... grrr)
Last edited by kraegar (17 March 2017 19:29)
Duet WiFi hardware designer and firmware engineerhttp://www.escher3d.comhttps://miscsolutions.wordpress.com
Love to see a pic of this assembled!
I like the way people are bolting on the rod end connectors so that the effector plate itself is very simple. Has this been done with regular (non-magnetic) rod ends?
Pics of it assembled are in the Gallery.
Maybe that was hiding too much.
Kraeger, are you still using seemecncs frame or did you ditch that too?
I have the melamine frame & 1x1 extrusions still, as well as the steppers, endstops, Onyx bed and Boro glass. Most of the rest of it's been gradually switched out for other parts. (Mostly because I can't leave things be, very few due to any real need to upgrade)
List of what I'm running now:Duet Wifi & PanelDuePiezo Z-ProbeE3D v6Dual E3D Titans (SeemeCNC Y Adapter)Custom Effector, 713maker mountHaydn's 304mm Magball armsTricklaser Aluminum Carriages12v PSU (newer one from SeeMeCNC)Aluminum Heat Spreader
Last edited by kraegar (19 March 2017 02:16)
I have a 713 maker mount for my e3d on my v2 max, but I'm using a printed effector on my kossel, I'd really like to use that mount on the kossel, but I'm not sure if he makes parts for other deltas.
Love to see a pic of this assembled!I like the way people are bolting on the rod end connectors so that the effector plate itself is very simple. Has this been done with regular (non-magnetic) rod ends?
I don't think it's possible with Traxxas or Igus joints because they don't have as much movement as the magnetic joints.
713 Maker will do custom jobs - that's what mine are. I modelled it in Fusion 360 and sent him a step file, and he cut them for me (He even took the time to trim down my designs to save weight, and was great to work with).
There's no reason you can't use his effectors on a kossel, just model what you want and he'll work with you on it.
I almost have all the same upgrades as you, kraegrer, except i got a trick laser effector instead of maker713.. i got maker713's first but because the ends of the spacers are glued in, I must of overtorked it and one of the threaded ends of the hotend mounting spacers popped out. Trick laser just uses a long screw and a metal standoff. Not as pretty, but it works 😁
Do you think the trick laser carriages are worth the $140? I'm trying to decide if want to put more money into a delta or start building a core xy instead. I've heard that core xy has the speed benefits of deltas without the geometry problems...
Last edited by Qdeathstar (19 March 2017 15:15)
The aluminum carriages are pretty nice. I'm happy with them - they feel more solid than the injection molded ones. I don't think they're $140, though.
I got way off on this tangent of trying to eliminate all tilt, etc in an effort to track down the "taco bowl" calibration I, and others, seem to get from them. Still haven't sorted that, but the tilt is gone 😁
I need to stop shovelling money into my delta, and start looking at a core-xy as well. Not because I'm unhappy with the Delta, I'm just nearing the point where I'm "happy" with it, and I'm ready to move on. The one major change I'm still weighing is the idea of going to 24v & 0.9 degree steppers before I call it "done".
I'm curious what will be at MRRF, though, there's usually at least one thing that makes me really consider another upgrade...
Yeah, its like $70 for the trucks and another ~65 for the wheels and hardware. Maybe you got a deal 😄 Looking at them it seems like they make belt tensioning a lot easier and are probably a lot more percise in terms of leveling... but, if i go with those i've got to get the magball arms 😄 SO thats like ~300 total, i could almost get everything i need for a 300mm x 300mm x 300mm core XY machine (using the electronics and steppers i've already got in the rostock)... although, going that route would mean to printer for a while, and you need a printer to make a printer... i'd hate having to wait for 3d printed parts from 3dhubs.
Last edited by Qdeathstar (19 March 2017 17:02)
Maybe I did pay that, and am in denial. 😄
Everything that trick laser has sent me has been top-notch. Not saying its not worth the price, just saying its making the decision harder...
They cleaned up my delta motion vs. the injection molded carriages. Not sure it was enough to actually see in a print, but it was measurable. I got their arms at the same time, but switched away from the ball cup design to magballs (hoping to sell the arms and get some of the $$ back at MRRF)
I updated the gallery, but here's the shot of my layer fans on my new plate.
Wow, that is just beautiful! How well does your Piezo Z-Probe work?